Call Today!
800-421-SEAL (7325)

Concrete Lifting vs. Replacement: Cost, Time, and Mess Compared

Concrete Lifting Vs. Replacement

When your concrete patios, walkways, or driveways settle, crack, or become uneven, you face two primary repair options: full concrete replacement or modern polyurethane concrete lifting (PolyLevel®). Below, we dive into the factors that matter—climate impacts, process overviews, cost and timeline comparisons, cleanup differences, technical details, FAQs, and more—to help you decide which solution is best for your home.

Concrete Settlement Causes: Freeze-Thaw, Drought & Heavy Rains

Concrete in the Chicagoland area faces a unique combination of stresses that accelerate settling and cracking:

  • Freeze-Thaw Cycles: Water seeps into cracks, freezes, and expands, opening gaps each winter.
  • Summer Droughts: Extended dry spells cause soil beneath slabs to shrink and pull away.
  • Heavy Spring & Summer Rains: Rapid saturation can wash out supporting soils, creating voids underneath the concrete.
  • Soil Swell-Shrink Behavior: Alternating wet/dry conditions cause expansive clay soils to swell when wet and shrink when dry.

Local Stat: In our Chicagoland and surrounding Midwest region, nearly 30% of residential slabs show measurable settling within five years.

Sinking and Uneven Concrete

Full Concrete Replacement: Process, Costs & Timeline

Many homeowners think that replacing the concrete is the best solution for settlement and cracks, but what are the hidden costs?

Concrete Replacement Steps:

  • Demolition & Removal: Jackhammer old slab into debris; haul it away.
  • Subgrade Preparation: Re-grade and compact soil; add gravel or sand.
  • Formwork & Pour: Build forms, pour fresh concrete, finish surface to spec.
  • Curing Time: Foot traffic in 24-72 hours; vehicles in 5-7 days.

Hidden Cost Drivers:

  • Labor & Time: Multiple crew members over several days.
  • Disposal Fees: Hauling broken concrete can cost $200-$500.
  • Permits: Municipal requirements add $50-$150.
  • Landscaping Repair: Adjacent lawns and plant beds often need restoration.

Polyurethane Concrete Lifting (PolyLevel®): Process & Benefits

PolyLevel® can bring settled concrete slabs back to level permanently with high-density foam that cures completely in as little as 2 hours.

Concrete Lifting Process:

  • Drill Ports: 3/4″ holes at low-spot locations.
  • Inject Foam: A two-component liquid expands 25x to fill voids and lift concrete.
  • Seal & Clean: Patch holes flush with grout; sweep surface clean.

Technical Highlights:

  • Foam Composition: Closed-cell urethane that’s waterproof and erosion-resistant.
  • Load Capacity: Supports over 8,000 psi—on par with new-pour concrete.
  • Cure Time: Surface ready for foot traffic in 15-20 minutes; vehicles in 1-2 hours.

Important Fact: PolyLevel®, also known as polyurethane concrete lifting, is a permanent fix. The high-strength 2-part foam is waterproof and erosion resistant, which means that it will stay strong and support your concrete through winter weather, heavy rain, and more. 

Cost Comparison: Replacement vs. Polyurethane Lifting

On average, PolyLevel® delivers 20-40% savings over replacement.

Method Cost per sq ft Total for 200 sq ft
Full Replacement $8–$15* $1,600–$3,000
PolyLevel® Concrete Raising $5–$7* $1,000–$1,400

*Pricing estimates for PolyLevel and traditional concrete replacement are based on an average project. Your project may vary. Free consultations and estimates are available from Perma-Seal before any work is done.

Timeline Comparison: Replacement vs. One-Day Concrete Raising

PolyLevel® restores your surface in a single day; replacement takes up to a week.

Method Cost per sq ft Total for 200 sq ft Total Duration Foot Traffic Vehicles
Full Replacement $8–$15 $1,600–$3,000 3–7 days 24–72 hours 5–7 days
PolyLevel® Concrete Raising $5–$7 $1,000–$1,400 1 day 15–20 minutes 1–2 hours

Cleanup Impact: Replacement Debris vs. Polyurethane Raising

Replacement Mess:

  • Piles of broken concrete and dust
  • Heavy equipment tracks on grass and driveways
  • Potential damage to irrigation lines or plant beds

Polyurethane Raising Cleanup:

  • Only drill-size holes are patched seamlessly
  • Virtually zero dust or debris
  • Landscape and hardscape remain intact

Before and After Concrete Leveling

Sidewalk Leveling After

Durability & Warranty: Why Choose Polyurethane Concrete Lifting

  • Resists Moisture & Erosion: Closed-cell structure won’t wash out.
  • Maintains Lift: Clients report zero settling even after multiple Chicago winters.
  • Supports Heavy Loads: More than 8,000 psi load capacity.
  • Backed by Warranty: Standard 5-year transferable warranty; optional upgrades to 10 years.

Resale Benefit: A transferable warranty can boost buyer confidence and home value.

Site Preparation & Service Expectations With Concrete Lifting

To ensure a smooth service day:

  • Clear the Area: Move furniture, planters, and vehicles off the slab.
  • Mark Utilities: Identify underground irrigation or lighting.
  • Plan for Noise: Foam injection is quiet; drilling makes light noise for 10-15 minutes.
  • Post-Service Care: Avoid heavy loads for 2 hours; no special maintenance afterward.

FAQs: Concrete Raising vs. Replacement Questions Answered

No—closed-cell polyurethane is waterproof and resists soil erosion.

Injection ports are patched to match the existing slab. For decorative finishes or color changes, replacement is a better option.
Most municipalities consider it a repair, not a new pour—permits are often unnecessary.
You can walk on in 15-20 minutes; drive on it after 1-2 hours.
Once cured, it’s inert and safe—no runoff or harmful chemicals will leach into the surrounding soil.

Choosing the Right Repair: Replacement vs. Polyurethane Raising

Choose Replacement if: Concrete is crumbling or structurally failing; you desire a fresh finish, color, or stamp.

Choose PolyLevel® Concrete Raising if: Slab is sound but uneven or sunken; you value speed, cost savings, and minimal yard impact.

Schedule a Free Estimate for Concrete Raising In Chicago

Don’t let settled concrete slow you down. Concrete raising is a quick and long-lasting way to fix your uneven concrete.

Schedule your free estimate with Perma-Seal today. Call 800-421-7325 or click the button below to fill out our online contact form.

Schedule a Free Consultation & Estimate

Schedule a Free Consultation & Estimate

Consent to Receive Communications
By submitting this form, I consent to receive communications from Perma-Seal Basement Systems via email, phone, and text messages, including automated messages and prerecorded/artificial voice messages, for marketing purposes and service updates. I understand that my consent is not a condition of purchase and that I can opt-out at any time. I also acknowledge that message and data rates may apply.